If I was to buy the framework, it would be to support the company and maybe flex it to fellow nerds that also know what it is.
In terms of the actual product, I really struggle to see the value in it, especially at the price point. I am currently using an x250 from 2015. Obviously, not everyone can do with an old laptop like that, but for me it’s a clear choice. The battery lasts me for about 12 hours while working, it has all the ports I need (minus an hdmi, which i use a dp dongle for). Going from a laptop that consumes about 3.5W while browsing to one that:
- takes 1.5 watt just to have an unused hdmi port plugged in
- you can’t really just throw in a backpack without worrying
- has a very “meh” performance for the pricepoint
- has no external battery
- has reports of mainboard parts randomly melting with no solution yet
- I am unsure about the promises of upgradeability so far.
It just feels like such a massive downgrade that I would struggle to justify it. Framework also prides itself on repairability. However, I dont think that there is anything more repairable about it than any old thinkpad prior to the XX80 series, where some still beat the FW in perfomance if you need a “modern” laptop. Plus, you can get parts much cheaper and have a great selection from multiple vendors.
I am incredibly greatful that framework exists, as there is a lack of current gen products with a promise of repairability, but my next laptop will probably be a cheaper, sturdier and more performant t480 from 2018/19 for less than 500€ or something like an T14. Those are probably even more upgradable than the framework (e.g. heatsinks, dGPU, magnesium case…) Unless aesthetics and an additional 5mm of slimness are that important to you, I feel like it is only the “brand” that would make anyone choose the framework over these.
If I was shopping for a paid for work laptop or had a high income I would buy the framework, but I currently can’t afford paying a 500€ premium for ideological reasons. Plus, I believe a used laptop will always be more sustainable than a new one. Maybe there will be an aftermarket for a potential framework pro in 3-4 years.
EDIT: I agree with the posters above that the lack of customization upon ordering is also a sustainability problem. If I ordered a FW now that is not my dream config due to current availability and then have to throw away a working screen/ keyboard/ mousepad to get the one I would like, I would just not upgrade it