Right fan randomly spins up to full speed

I’ve been having a rather strange issue with my Framework 16. At random times, the right fan spins up to full speed. I’ve had this happen when the system is idle and under no load, when the system is under heavy load, and even while the system is suspended. It’s also happened both on battery and AC-powered operation. Only the right fan in the expansion bay shell is affected, I’ve never observed this phenomenon with the left fan.

Here comes the strangest part: A reliable way to get the fan to stop going full speed and return to normal operation seems to be to pick the laptop up off of whatever surface it is sitting on and gently tilt it. This gets the fan to spin down right away. Perhaps there is some loose contact. It’s not related to the laptop being sat on a surface though, as it’ll also happen when I’m holding the laptop in my hand, and I’ve also found no other reliable way of reproducing the issue.

I have not opened up the laptop prior to this happening, however around a month ago before this has started, I’ve also received a strange message from the BIOS before boot claiming that it can’t detect an expansion bay module installed. I had also not opened up the laptop before that, and it stopped showing after maybe two or three boots. The fans have also always worked fine until just a few days ago.

# framework_tool --expansion-bay
Expansion Bay
  Enabled:       false
  No fault:      true
  Door closed:   true
  Board:         UmaFans
  Serial Number: UMA FAN

While it's happening (system under load):
# framework_tool --thermal -vv
  F75303_Local: 47 C
  F75303_CPU:   47 C
  F75303_DDR:   57 C
  APU:          82 C
  dGPU VR:      0 C
  dGPU VRAM:    0 C
  dGPU AMB:     0 C
  dGPU temp:    NotPowered
  Left Fan:      0 RPM
  Right Fan:  5401 RPM
[INFO ]   Fan 2:      Not present
[INFO ]   Fan 3:      Not present

After picking up the laptop and tilting it:
# framework_tool --thermal -vv
  F75303_Local: 48 C
  F75303_CPU:   49 C
  F75303_DDR:   57 C
  APU:          87 C
  dGPU VR:      0 C
  dGPU VRAM:    0 C
  dGPU AMB:     0 C
  dGPU temp:    NotPowered
  Left Fan:   3627 RPM
  Right Fan:  1649 RPM
[INFO ]   Fan 2:      Not present
[INFO ]   Fan 3:      Not present

Setup Info

  • OS: NixOS on nixos-unstable-small
  • Product: Framework Laptop 16 with Ryzen 9 7940HS
  • Expansion bay module: Expansion bay shell
  • Firmware Version: 0.0.4.5 (newest at time of posting according to fwupd)

I managed to fix this: turns out I didn’t tighten the motherboard-side screw of the expansion bay interposer tightly enough. It needs to be very tight, apparently. I got this idea after stumbling over this post: Solved] - Framework 16 5070 Expansion bay not recognized - #25 by Raven_Popescu