[TRACKING] FW12 cracking issue

I just checked the bottom of mine again, which is the replacement I got in December, and there’s no cracks on it yet. My first bottom cover started cracking within the first week or so, and so I’m optimistic that this one isn’t going to crack. My replacement is also dated before the fix; I don’t remember what the date was but I think I posted it somewhere in this thread.

1 Like

That’s good to hear. Hopefully for everyone’s sake, this issue is put behind us all soon.

As for me, I’m hesitant to even bother doing anything further about it. Originally, Framework was encouraging everyone to submit tickets so they could track the issue and get to the bottom of it. So far, the cracks have never affected my ability to use the machine. So, it’s starting to feel like a waste of everyone’s time and effort for me to keep telling support about new cracks.

It sucks that it keeps cracking and I really wish it wasn’t. But I’m starting to feel like, yup, my top and bottom case are cracked. Oh, well. The continuous back and forth with support, shipping things back and forth, etc., just…I’ve got so much else going on right now and I just don’t know if I have enough extra Fs lying around to give, lol. That’s why I didn’t bother following up with support after waiting weeks for an update on the manufacture date of the bottom cover I was sent. I just installed the bottom cover I was sent and moved on. Now that one’s cracking and I just don’t know if it’s worth anyone’s time to find out if the forth time’s the charm.

2 Likes

Little update: It’s been almost two months since I received my replacement bottom cover and I still see no sign of any cracks on either the top or bottom covers. It’s still used every day for many hours of drawing or gaming.

I think it might be safe to say it won’t crack, knock on wood.

I finally feel safe enough to put stickers on it. :slight_smile:

11 Likes

Hey! Since there was some internal miscommunication about a couple of colors having the new material in stock back in Nov / Dec… I’d recommend getting it replaced one more time. Of course, it’s your decision.

6 Likes

Is there a timeframe for when the issue was resolved? For example, I just got a new FW12 delivered about a week ago (in Bubblegum). Is it safe to assume it’s likely okay? Thanks! :slight_smile:

Do you see any new cracks with your latest replacement?

I was one of the first to report the issue and had a replacement unit early on. Got a replacement pretty soon. It was more in the spirit of giving them a unit to analyze instead of expecting an immediate fix. The replacement unit cracked as expected.

I then decided to wait with the next replacement until after there were user reports (since FW does not really communicate) that gave me reasonable confidence that the issue was sorted out. I reached out last week and got my replacement today. It says manufacture date 08/2025. Seems really odd - don’t think they fixed it by then, but we’ll see. Fully expect having to waste time with this issue again soon.

@Eagle can you tell us the manufacturing dates from when the issue was definitely fixed?

1 Like

I think they fixed the issue around late November because that’s when I got my actually refreshed bottom cover.

There seems to be some obvious either ignorance or miscommunication in Framework support for them to keep saying that they’re shipping new bottom covers when they aren’t.

Feels like my issue only got solved when Eagle took over my ticket and personally made sure I got a refreshed cover. It was very nice of Eagle to do that but it shouldn’t be necessary for something as basic as this.

Framework support is very liberal with replacement parts but ample parts don’t matter when they break after a week. It’s frustrating.

1 Like

That’s what I’m worried about. So much wasted resources for Framework and for us too - considering constantly having to spend time on this.

If they really sent me a unit that still does have the known issue it’s just plain stupid. Fingers crossed it ain’t so, but if they don’t deploy common sense in the way they handle this situation it does not give much hope for the company at large.

Support and I agreed very clearly that I wanted to only exchange once this issue is fixed. If their support team is not able to grasp that, then I’m just at a loss for words at this point.

I hate hate hate the non-communication. No clear statement about what happened, no info on when it was fixed, if they really have it under control now. So frustrating.

3 Likes

It might be frustrating but they’re more transparent than every other computer manufacturer. Trying to get anything out of any other manufacturer is futile, and a lot of times their support is horrific. For instance I broke the screen on my Minisforum V3 tablet replacing the SSD and it took something like 3-4 months and numerous emails to get a new screen from them, and I paid for it myself and said I would pay for it in the initial email.

4 Likes

It’s really easy to be a decent computer company when the bar set by the competition is at the bottom of the ocean. Repairable products and easily accessible replacement parts used to be normal.

If we were frogs, we got boiled a long time ago by Apple, Microsoft and the like. It’s Sad

2 Likes

I want them to succeed. That’s why I had a FW13, now FW12 + Desktop.

Still don’t agree how they handle communications with manufacturing issues. Thinking back to the FW13 Intel 11th gen CMOS battery issue where I was initially gaslit by support insisting there was no issue - even when showing them the public post hidden in some forum thread by nrp where he acknowledged the issue but no other public confirmation at all for a while.

I applaud them for really trying hard to make their customers right in the end. Also now with the cracked chassis and the Desktop PSU fan situation.

Still don’t agree with how they handle public communication. I’m trying to tell myself that there must be reasons I’m just not seeing. Something forcing them to do what they do, that I have no knowledge of. I stopped advocating for them to do things differently because of that reasoning. My own frustrations from a customer POV are still valid and I can disagree.

Leaving communications aside - to keep sending out units with known issues for months is something else IMO. Especially since I was in contact with support and we both agreed I’ll get a replacement once units are available that are not affected anymore.

To be fair - at this point it could very well be that 08/2025 for the gray model is fine. As there is no public info on the state I can only speculate, wait, and see. That was the main motivation to ask @stag90 and @Eagle

1 Like

You rang? :grinning_face_with_smiling_eyes: I can’t remember the different dates for all of the colors and categories. I’ll check to see if I can track that info down.

We initially ended up with 3 ‘buckets’.

  1. The category with the risk materials. We stopped sending these out once the issue was identified.
  2. The category (I call it the ‘intermediate’ category) where we adjusted some things and sent the hardware back through inspection with the risk materials removed. These were sent out on the worst cases or for those customers who couldn’t wait for the resolution. Some colors in this category also accidentally were sent out as ‘new material’ due to a miscommunication internally. I think that’s referenced in this thread somewhere.
  3. The units with all new material and design

Never fear though, we’ll take care of it if you happen to have a crack show up with this issue.

9 Likes

Dates would be really helpful.

Really appreciate those additional details. You have no idea how much of a difference that makes.

Will keep an eye on my (hopefully final) replacement unit and report back here in a few weeks.

Thank you.

I went ahead and reached out to support for an update. In late December they said they were going to escalate my ticket and look into the situation with the date on the cover I was sent. I haven’t heard back, so I sent in some pics of the new cracks (bottom cover and top cover) and asked for an update. I suppose if I can get parts with the new material and design that won’t crack again, that would be nice. We’ll see what they say. Cheers!

2 Likes

Cool! Yell if you need me. Happy to help!

2 Likes

Thanks for the update!

My confusion came from waiing for 3 months for the new design, and I got an old one nevertheless.

My lazy ass didn’t get myself to replace it yet :frowning:

1 Like

@Eagle This is getting ridiculous. The machine is again already forming a new crack around one of the corner screws.

I’ve gone through two replacements now. It was my own initiative to stall the second replacement for several months to be sure the issue is fixed. Support would have sent another replacement much earlier. They assured me this was indeed fixed and it will not happen again.

Can you please give us a clear answer? Is this fixed? And if so - when was that? How can I get a unit that is not defective?

3 Likes

Hey Wolfie!

Sorry to hear you’re having some troubles. According to the product teams:: All colors of the replacement bottom covers should be all new material if marked 50 week of 2025 or after. Which one is yours? Shoot me a DM if you’d like and I’ll get a new one on it’s way to you.

1 Like

I noticed you didn’t say “fixed”. Does that mean the change possibly did not fix the cracking issue? I bought a lavender a couple weeks ago and hope we don’t have this cracking problem.