Saw some interest here in an ethernet card - I have a few different tricks that might allow for one to juuuuuuuuuuust squidge into the same size as other expansion cards. But I don’t have a framework yet (part because of the ethernet thing, but mostly just because I’m not in desperate need of a laptop), so I was wondering if anyone could measure the space under the rear expansion cards to the table. double height cards are no fun imo 
15 Likes
I measure 3.45mm with a micrometer.
4 Likes
awesome, thanks. that should mean it’s just barely doable
just to check, what exactly did you measure there?
another sanity check someone should probably do- see if an ethernet cable goes into an expansion slot when the laptop is on a surface. tab down ideally cos that’d be this guy works
1 Like
Pardon the mess…
Pardon the extreme closeup…
It does, just barely. The tab does extend below the underside of the laptop though (hits the edge of the desk quite solidly there). As for the anti-snag tab, fuggetaboutit.
6 Likes
tysm dude!
it’s a little cryptic, but this is the sort of thing i had in mind. you can see the pcb (1mm thick), the usb plug and ethernet jack. on the side 6.8mm is the size of the expansion card.
4 Likes
today’s test- can a 3d print hold in an ethernet cable (yes)
just downloaded a model online for a quick check, so it’s a fair bit taller than the plan. next up- model the jack i wanna use, and then the bottom half as a separate piece
i didn’t mention it yet, but my endgame here is to have a folding jack like on some other laptops. so it fits fully in the expansion slot when stowed, as well as under the laptop when deployed
3 Likes
Ever considered the Fujitsu Ethernet jack? It folds into the laptop nicely with anti-tripping safety mechanism.
18 Likes
That ethernet jack is certainly a big inspiration for this project 
that said, this requires both halves of the ethernet jack to move, which I think would be a pain in the butt, and I don’t really know how you’d do that reliably, especially with off the shelf parts. not seen any teardowns or available replacement parts to have a look at either.
The four bar linkage is something I might use though.
2 Likes
today, I modelled an expansion card from scratch (well, the annoying parts
) if there are any fusion users here, I’d like to slightly humblebrag about how nice the timeline looks 
this means I wont be modifying a step file to make my own enclosure, which would probably make me wanna rip my hair out. If anyone’s interested in the file- here it is if anyone w/ a 3d printer and a framework would like to test it, would be mucho appreciated <3
6 Likes
Designed and printed this guy today- based off of the ethernet port I printed before and the expansion card I modelled yesterday.
You can see it a) holds an ethernet cable and b) just fits under the reported height of the laptop
there is certainly room that could be shaved off still, plus the final hinged design will sort of cheat in this regard I think- since it will be spring loaded, it’ll push itself back in towards the laptop, allowing it to fit in a shorter profile than a regular old ethernet jack.
Other thing I’ve been working on- a case and pcb outline. The connector I’m using doesn’t stick out as far as the molex one, so I’ve made a little cutout for it.
I feel like this connector would be nicer than a midmount one for a breakout / prototyping PCB, since you get more Z height on the top side. wonder if anyone would be interested in that?
11 Likes
lil progress update- started the PCB. honestly wasnt sure if this was possible when I started. but it is. barely
22 Likes
This is great. One thing to check is on the magnetics. Were you able to find a way to fit the magnetics required for one of the compact jacks that doesn’t have integrated magnetics?
11 Likes
Yep those squares are transformers, and the rectangles are the common mode chokes.
7 Likes
progress update- got in my component order today, including these little connectors
Made a 3D printed “PCB” and case to try it all out in-
Looking good so far. next up is to figure out the hinging bottom part, which is gonna be a huge pain in the butt tbh. I’ve got a few ideas though.
those are some cool looking connectors, especially the built in LED ones. your google-fu is clearly better than mine since I’ve not seen those before. That said, I don’t think any of those fit quuuite as well this one. certainly worth thinking about if it turns out being a bust though.
12 Likes
I know this is a bit late in the game, and I have seen this posted in other ethernet expansion card topics, but have you looked into IX Industrial connectors? It’s a new connector standard that is being marketed as an RJ45 alternative for ethernet connections. The connectors are similar in size/slightly smaller than USB type-A connectors. They also already make pre-made ethernet cables with an IX connector on one end and a RJ45 connector on the other end. I don’t think this would be a full replacement for the RJ45 module you are currently designing as those cables are everywhere, but if you want an ethernet module that is standard size, this may be the way to go for version 2.
Below is a link to a Digi-Key search for the IX Industrial connectors - I’m not affiliated with them in any way, but my company uses Digi-Key to purchase a lot of our components and electronic parts, so I trust them and know they are a good source for connectors and other components.
https://www.digikey.com/en/products/filter/pluggable-connectors/443?s=N4IgjCBcoBwAwWiAxlALgJwK4FMA0IA9lANogDMAnAEyUBscIAugQA5pQgDKmAlgHYBzEAF8RBaqRABJAB4ACAQBMsAZz4BDADbMRQA
3 Likes
Whenever I see something being marketed as a new standard for an old one, I can only think of it as something like xkcd: Standards, haha.
9 Likes
They start at 5/5.2 mm in height and go up, and they can be mid-mounted. Might be possible?
What connector is that? Did you modify it? I didn’t really find another half-connectors besides the Singatron ones. Hirose had a latching one, but it’s been recently discontinued.
2 Likes
progress update- good news and bad news though
designed and printed a live hinge-type case.
It works… kinda. holds in a cable, but will come out if you pull it at some angles. Just a proof of concept though, I think a better design would be doable, and I certainly wouldn’t wanna use a live hinge in the real deal. However…
The thickness of the whole thing is too big to fit under the framework 
I measured 10.6mm when I was squishing the whole thing down. The issue is that there’s an extra 0.85mm step in the connector for some reason, which I didn’t account for in my initial drawing:
I think that the whole concept- that is, a gigabit ethernet expansion card which stays inside the expansion card while folded, and under the laptop while unfolded- is still possible though- you’d just need a connector that
a) stayed under the height limit of pcb (4.65 mm. maybe a bit higher if you can leave the bounding box of the card and go up into the laptop a bit?) and
b) had a smaller “top portion”- The one I used had a 1.7mm top portion, and was 4.7mm above the pcb- either deep in the depths of the chinese markets, or a custom tooled one, though this one @taeyeon suggested is close (4.8mm above pcb, 1.1mm top portion). I’m pretty sure that the “origami” style connector would go too far into the laptop- the USB connector would get in the way.
Alas- I think I’m gonna throw in the towel. The only people with the resources to pull off something like this would be framework themselves… you guys up for it? ;p (feel free to dm me if you want anything, this would be great to see, real engineering masterpiece)
8 Likes
Some great work here. I’m no electrical or mechanical engineer, but I definitely appreciate the challenges faced.
Curious about the option for something like the old 3Com/Megahertz XJACK connectors. Seems like this could meet all the requirements. Not sure if those are available commercially, or if there are licensing/patent issues though.
2 Likes