Minisforum ms-s1 max is about to launch with dgpu support

Wasn’t that true of Framework also before they shipped any units?

I hope someone tests the PCIe slot - does it actually work with low profile GPUs?

there is :

  • 4x PCIe for the “16x” PCIe socket
  • 4x PCIe for 1 NVMe
  • 1x PCIe for 2e NVMe !!!
  • 2 PCIe for the 2 10Gb eth
  • 1 (or 2?) for the Wifi/BT (if it is in a normal M2 socket like framework it is 2)
    => 12/13 lines use on the 16
    => there is only at mose 4x PCie left (may be more 2x) for the USB4 V2.0
    => at most 2x 32Gb/s data path for the 2x USB4 V2. (but may be only 16Gb/s)

On framework ther is:

  • 1 HDMI
  • 2 DP
    vs only 1 HDMI output.
    => so more likely that it is “only” for hight speed DP output.

The only thing missing for me on the framework is the 2 USB2 ports. I find it a shame to use USB3 ports to connect my keyboard/mouse :wink:

1 Like

It’ll be interesting to hear your review @workintw Thank you for taking the risk

I’m quite sure, given the NVIDIA GPU add on for the FW16 that there would have been a few conversations about an add-on GPU for the Desktop. I mean, they clearly understand their market wants my GPU, otherwise why do the add-on?

My disappointment is that there has been silence on these questions from this community to the Framework team. I understood, from @Lukew4lker, that Framework may be deliberately diswading adding a GPU via firmware design. That would be something that should be explained by FW.

I don’t thing there is anything in BIOS that restrict dGPU support from FW.
But this API is not design for dGPU:
it has only 16 line of PCIE4 (no PCIE-5 .)
some a needed for ethernet / wifi and 4 for a Nvme… so most likely no more than 8 is available for anything else.

the chose is:

  • 1 8x PCie 4.0 and nothing else
  • 1 4x PCie 4.0 and 1 more M2 x4 SSD => this is the chose of FW.

Never GPU have PCie 5.0 connection 8x (for lower) or 16x for bigger. use it on 4xPCIe 4.0 mean 1/4 or 1/8 of the design bandwidth => for me it is rely not interesting to use a recent dGPU in that case (This is my personal opinion.)

For me this x4 PCie4 (64Gbit/s == 8GByte/s vs 256GByte/s of the RAM) is for small Pcie Card:

  • 1 more NVMe
  • hight speed Ethernet ( 25/40Gbit/s => did not find one with PCie4.0)
  • SATA connection
    …

the FW16 AMD Ryzen™ 9 7940HS have 20 Pcie lines so it have a 8x Pcie4 connection for the GPU .
the new FW16 300 serie have made some chose because it have only 16 Pcie line:

  • 1 NVMe is a 4x
  • 1 NVMe is a 2x (vs 4x on Ryzen 7X40HS)

Looks like the PCIe slot in Minisforum is just 1-slot width, and no extra power connectors are available. The internal space is very tight too and not enough ventilation is available there, so I guess it’s better suited for Oculink adapter use case than dGPU.

Given this and complains about fan noise, I’m going to stick with my Framework preorder.

At least Framework motherboard is standard mini-ITX design, so if someone comes up with a riser solution for x4 slot, it will be a better path forward.

2 Likes

I see that the MS-S1 runs the Intel JHL9580 TB5 chip. IOMMU groups can be seen at 17:45 in this vid. A bit further on (21:50) you get to hear the fans that are “nice and quiet”

1 Like

and only a Low Profile to.
I don’t tink anyone can find a GPU to fit.

So if for dGPU you need a external card with OCuLink it is working on Framework laptop to, nothing new.

1 Like

They will have a motherboard version, just like Framework

1 Like

Got any supporting links? There is nothing about it on their website.

Nope, they haven’t publish any news yet, I have a friend has connection with them and told me this.

The difference is the motherboard version doesn’t have TB5.

1 Like

for rack support there is now:

for framework desktop MB… and other ITX MB.

1 Like

Do you think it will be a promising choice? bios and build quality wise.

I would be INCREDIBLY careful before ordering this. First of all, it doesn’t have enough lanes to accommodate all those interfaces. AMD’s Strix Halo APU is equipped with a total of 16 PCIe Gen 4.0 lanes. Second, I have had VERY bad luck with my former MINI IS FORUM using cheap and defective chipsets (ESP FOR USB!). Mine died after about a year. The thermals on it were WAY high and I think it killed itself for heat death.

1 Like

Thanks for the first hand info!

No you can not fit any GPU inside. There is a review on Reddit about it. It can fit for sure an OCuLink card but we do not know if it will work with a dGPU first we heard from Minisforum is that not likely at the moment may require BIOS update. The connector is x16 standard PCIe but it has x4 lanes available which is enough for OCuLink, but the story about BIOS is concerning. Also there is no confirmation that they did test the TB5 ports with a TB5 dGPU dock, so again we do not know if require again BIOS changes, which may or may not come. Looks like some units are out to reviewers, does not look bad in general but nobody was interested to see if supports or not and external dGPU, most do not need one. They were left with only 1x PCI for the second NVMe but if you do not need OCuLink the internal PCIe supports an NVMe 4x adaptor, and this was tested and works OK so you could have in fact 3 NVMe but one is 1800 Mb/s, but two are full speed. The TB5 controller they use is confirmed to be Intel JHL9480 so the same as most TB5 eGPU docks out there but again we do not have any confirmation that they tested and that works with an eGPU. We could not even confirm that it works with the dock they build which is a standard USB4 one. It has 2 x 10Gb/s Realtek ethernet ports, the driver is in mainline Linux from kernel 6.16 and up, and it is confirmed that works once you update the kernel. Did not hear any complains about not working in Windows.

Some initial reviews complained about fan noise in performance mode, looks like they already released a new BIOS with improvements, they can control the fans in BIOS. I do not think anybody really tested how much the new BIOS improve the noise but is good that they were fast to at least try to fix it.

If I hear anything new, I will update here also, I’m keeping an eye on it, once a few things get clarified. I do have a Minisforum system, more than 3 years old and never had any problems with it, so depends of luck.

I do not need an eGPU now but I would like to have the option, I read about progress in this forum for using hybrid LLMs iGPU + dGPU working together so I would like to have the option in the future. The system looks very promising, if all things will work as supposed to.

5 Likes

I’m afraid they can’t resolve the AMD dGPU issue, but Nvidia works

1 Like

I have a feeling will be the same with Minisforum pc if using an OCuLink adaptor, looks like the problem may come deep from Agesa. Probably the BIOS does not consider NVidia as a “gpu” at that level this is why passes some of initialization and AMD dGPU does not. This probably only AMD can fix. But it may work on Minisforum with the TB5 port and an eGPU dock, who knows. They start shipping units to reviewers but is just standard talk, no reviewer is interested in these kind of testing, is yet again all the general AI 395 stuff, same as with every other model.

I wish ETA Prime could test this and show us something.

But YES, the problem only AMD can resovle

1 Like