Minisforum ms-s1 max is about to launch with dgpu support

Can someone help me understand, beyond the marketing, what “Thunderbolt ready” really means, please?

Intel markets “Thunderbolt Ready” as a motherboard that is compatible with their JHL9580 TB5 chip. These boards can, apparently, take a 4x thunderbolt 5 card with JHL9580 and tunnel double the 40Gbs of TB4 or USB4 V1

Then alongs come the MS-S1 with a few of these Barlow Ridge JHL9580 chips and it’s USB 4 V2 and it’s (untested) 80Gbs.

What does “Ready” actually mean? Is it possible to simply add a TB5 card into the Desktop x4 PCIe slot to achieve USB4 V2 throughput?

I think the controller is JHL9840 this is what Minisforum is using, this is what I found about:

Also from what I read is using 4x PCIe lanes so the data connection can not be more than that so 64 Gbs, 80Gbs is for video in DP Alt mode they do some compression or encoding for that. But anyway 64Gbs is twice as much as TB4/USB4 and on par with OCuLink. In fact it will be a little bit under because some overhead from what I read is 95% of OCuLink which is not bad.

Sadly, it seems this does not apply universally. I found this really nice writeup on egpu.io. There’s a really nice comparison table right below the “Benchmarks” heading: https://egpu.io/forums/builds/2024-asus-prime-z890-p-wifi-rtx-3090-cu214ck-rtx-3090-ti-64gbps-tb5-razer-core-x-v2-linux-win11-24h2/

That’s not what comes up in the IOMMU here

Interesting, this is what a reviewer with a unit found, probably reported by Windows drivers. What is the difference between the two ?

Found this, still not clear, appears that 40 is a quad and 50 is dual.

Anyway Minisforum specify 2 x USB4V2. Maybe is just a Windows reporting error they look pretty similar. Or maybe they are pin to pin compatible and Minisforum used both on the sample units they send out.

1 Like

From the tables TB5-TB5 results are close to that 95% of OCuLink with some games better than other. Anyway, for local LLMs using the dGPU for hybrid work I doubt that the difference is even visible.

If you do the math - TB5-TB5 ext vs. OCuLink ext - only the Timespy Extreme score has <5% difference. But looking at the other (ext) results, Timespy Extreme seems almost completely invariant on bandwidth.
For everything else tested we’re looking at 5.5-8% difference with a whopping 25% diff in Aida mem write.

Personally, TB5 is a no go for me when compared to OCuLink because I like to use the “int” variant which seems to work way better with OCuLink than with TB5. Plugging the display (or display dummy) to the iGPU allows the dGPU to enter d3cold when unused and drain close to zero power.

For now Minisforum has the same problem like the Framework when trying to use an AMD dGPU on the PCIe slot. Pretty sure will be the same with the OCuLink. Probably an NVidia will work but nobody did test yet, again probably similar to Framework. But TB5 port works.

Yeah, that was to be expected… pretty frustrating…

I understood the Framework has 1 PCIe channel for the Wifi and a USB for the Bluetooth. Bluetooth isn’t fast enough to need a full PCIe channel.

Yes, the M2 module uses 1 x PCIe for WIFI and 1 xUSB3.0 for BT. Anyway, for the Minisforum pc, they have left 4x PCIe lanes available on the connector. But the second NVMe was left with only 1x PCIe lane, its on specs. All other lanes are used, they need some for the TB5 controller also. There are already units out for reviewers, looks good. Expected general shipping to start by the end of October.