The small battery charge cycling recently introduced - aging the battery?

The EC controls the power profiles.
You can see them being set with “ectool console”
e.g. On my FW16 7840HS with iGPU, when set to “balanced” power profile.
PMF: SPL 43000mW, sPPT 52000mW, fPPT 65000mW, p3T 227000mW, ao_sppt 0mW

To me the interesting one is the P3T one. I have a FW 180W power adapter. So that profile is letting that peak to 227W, thus to provide 227W, it would need 180W from the power adapter and 57W from the battery, thus discharging the battery a bit.
This is generally what you see, the CPU peaking over 180W for very short periods, using up a small amount of battery.
When that battery gets below a certain threshold, the EC switches to charging battery mode.
80W approx goes to charging the battery, leaving about 100W for the CPU.
One possible problem, is that while charging, it still has p3T 227000mW.
I don’t exactly see how it can supply 227W if its not able to pull the extra from the battery, which it cannot while in charging mode.

I have not tested, but I would think, setting p3T to say 80W would mean the CPU never pulls peak power above what the PSU can supply, and thus the battery would never discharge when the PSU is plugged in. I think that would have been a better profile for “Balanced” mode.

That, combined with a EC bug where the PMF power profile messages sometimes get slilently ignored by the CPU/APU, is I think what contributes to discharge/charge cycle problems.

There is also the complication of the dGPU expansion card and the power it draws, but I don’t have one of those so cannot comment there.

There was a test done by one user with a dGPU, and they managed to get it to draw about 400W peak. Only for a very short time, but it did happen.