Hey everyone,
I own a Framework 13 AMD for 2 months (and I loved it so far…) which two weeks ago started crashing randomly (multiple times a day) while using it.
Specs:
AMD Ryzen 7 7840U
DDR5-5600 - 64GB (2 x 32GB)
WD_BLACK SN850X NVMe - M.2 2280 - 2TB
OSs:
I have Windows 10, Fedora 40 KDE and Pop! OS 22.04 installed in parallel and the crashes happen on all of them.
Symptoms:
Generally the OSs work fine, except the usual suspend issues on Linux (sometimes not waking up but rebooting instead or black screen after waking up).
When the OSs crash it is mostly happening while watching videos or gaming. Temperatures are completely fine (below 60°C, I most of the times run the energy saving power profiles in the OSs anyway, even when being connected to power, no fans going crazy or similar).
Crashing on Windows means:
- flickering screen with artifacts (like for a faulty graphics driver)
- instant reboot
- no event logs for the crash except “kernel power 41”, no warnings beforehand or similar
Crashing on Linux is consistent between Pop and Fedora and means:
- Screen goes black, sometimes chopped audio artifacts
- instant reboot
- no indicator in journalctl, nothing suspicious in the last log entries before the crashes happen
What I did already:
- running memtester multiple times, tested 50GB of the 64GB RAM, the rest was allocated already and no issues were found
- installing latest drivers for the OSs, performing firmware/chipset and BIOS update, issue still present
Any ideas how I can narrow it down? I fear it’s a hardware issue but I’m wondering how I would debug it properly.
Many thanks in advance!
1 Like
Welcome to the community!
It does sound like a hardware issue, but it may well be a correctable one. I would suggest trying the method outlined here first; if that fails, scroll up a little to see my original post on how to force it. That technique seems to solve a number of hardware-related problems, large and small.
If the problem persists, you’ll likely need to talk to Framework’s support team.
Good luck!
And please let us know how/whether that works for you.
Interesting, I have a non-Framework laptop using the same AMD platform, and I’m observing the same kind of problems. RAM is ok as tested by memtest86+, nothing in the logs, just insta-reboot, vaguely reminiscent of what happens when some kind of overvoltage/overcurrent kicks in.
My system is GPD Win with a 7840HS inside, so yeah, but I’m just hoping against all hope the fix for the Framework could apply to my system, too.
I, however, have been so far unable to pin this on any particular graphics usage or CPU load (mine can reboot even when idle).
The only very finicky idea that’s on my mind right now is to set up continuous monitoring of all possible sensors and immediately sending them over the network so that hopefully a spike in temperature/voltage can be seen as close to the crash as possible.
I have tried setting up netconsole for the Linux kernel, but there wasn’t anything useful in the kernel log at the time of reboot. No warnings, no nothing. So very likely a firmware/hardware level protection kicking in.
Thanks to both of you for your input and apologies for the late response.
Thanks, Chad! Re-inserting the extension cards as described in your linked post seems to have helped. I did not see a single issue since then. While I did not use the laptop super heavily in the last week due to being on holiday the crashes/freezes did not happen again so far. I’ll push the machine a bit more in the next weeks and keep an eye on how it behaves. But I’m hopeful this might have been it.
Jaroslaw, sorry, that this is probably not helping you with your issue. I hope you get it sorted out.
Thanks again for your support and keep up being an awesome community.
1 Like
Running into the same issue (instant reboot) with my FW13 7840U 64GB RAM, journalctl has no indication of a crash. Running openSUSE Tumbleweed using the latest firmware/bios.
I’m curious if this is load-dependent. I was having this issue on Gnome frequently until I disabled file indexing. However, with KDE I get it more often (even with file indexing turned off) which has caused me to start looking for solutions.
I assume it’s also worth noting that I’m almost always running my laptop docked to a Caldigit TB4 with a high refresh rate 4k display connected, so obviously there’s a bit more stress involved than with the laptop undocked.
1 Like
Wondering if there are any new ideas about what might be causing this. I have the same issue that I believe only happens when I am plugged into an Aorus gaming box eGPU.
Hey everyone, quick update from me:
The instant reboot issues were gone for about a week and then returned. I needed to reach out to FW support and meanwhile got my mainboard and CPU replaced.
It was not the greatest customer experience since it took me weeks to convince them that it is a hardware issue but eventually they sent me replacement parts and after replacing the board I - so far - did not have a single instant reboot in 1 1/2 months.
Running dual boot with Fedora 40 Plasma and Win 11 right now (with other distros/OSs you will not get support at all) and it finally feels like I’m having a reliable machine in hands.
I hope you guys get your issues sorted out.
2 Likes