TLDR: Here’s how I got rid of the issue: I send back the laptop and got a refund.
This is not a solution to the shutdown problem. I just want to share what I did in case someone else is considering that option.
I purchased a 12th gen i5 Laptop in 2022 and quickly started experiencing the shutdown issues described in this thread. I got in touch with the support, did what they asked me to do, and at some point, they send me a replacement mainboard. I reinstalled Windows and went through many hours of troubleshooting, just like many other people in this thread.
I also had several other problems:
- The fingerprint reader stopped working after a while until rebooting the device or disabling and reenabling it in the device manager. A replacement input cover didn’t change anything. I found out that the issue was related to the Thunderbolt dongle I used, so I got a different one which avoided the problem.
- My storage expansion card and sometimes even the external monitor briefly or permanently disconnected when I inserted a USB device on a different USB port.
- To solve this problem, the support recommended to install the beta BIOS update. This did not help but added a new issue: When connecting a USB 3 device to a port for the third time in a row, the USB port was somehow disabled and could only be revived by removing and reinserting the USB A expansion card.
As a response to those issues, Framework asked me to send the laptop to a local repair company called “LetMeRepair” here in Germany. A few weeks after shipping the laptop there, I asked how the repair was going. I only got very vague responses. At some point I was informed that the mainboard had been replaced again (that’s the third mainboard for that laptop).
Seven weeks after sending back the laptop, I set a deadline for the repair. Working with the dinosaur of a laptop I used as a replacement was just getting too annoying. Framework only send me another vague response.
This is why, nine weeks after sending back the laptop, I rescinded from the purchasing contract in accordance with § 323 BGB (German Law, this may be helpful if it applies to you: Übersicht: Gewährleistungsrechte des Käufers – LawAndLegal ). I also talked to a lawyer to confirm that my interpretation of the law is correct. Framework accepted my decision by making “an exception from their return policy” because of the “error in return handling” or something like that. Eleven weeks after returning the device, Framework refunded the money.
Needless to say, I am not happy with the way my decision to buy a Framework laptop ended. I still really believe in the idea behind the company, I think right to repair, upgradeability and sustainability are super important, and I liked the laptop, but I was so frustrated with their ignorance towards the problem we have here. This laptop was by far the most expensive thing I’ve bought in my entire life, and I really wanted it to be reliable and last a long time.
And to be clear: I do not blame the local repair company for any of this. Their task was basically impossible to do because it would have required extensive troubleshooting and time-consuming analysis and most likely changes to the software, not just replacing some obviously faulty component.
In case anyone at Framework is reading this and actually wants to change something, here’s what I would have wanted:
- Take your customers issues seriously.
- Value my time. I felt like the support agents didn’t care that they took one to two days out of my life every time they told me to reinstall Windows, because I need to set everything up again afterwards. I would have liked to just hand the troubleshooting to them at this point.
- Keep me updated and send me a replacement device if whatever repair you need to do takes more than two months!
I’m just glad this is over.