Thanks a lot for the recommendations, I think we are trying a niche setup here, so any feedback is super helpful. I was already leaning toward a Corsair SFX PSU, so hearing you have had a great experience with them is reassuring.
On the dock, I am tempted to just grab the DEG1 since it sounds like the it simply works option, and I am trying to get up and running quickly. I may use the Amazon rental program in the gentlest way possible, since I am still not totally sure the DEG2 features would matter for my use.
My understanding is that Framework 16 OCuLink is still PCIe 4.0 x 4 on either model, so the extra DEG2 capabilities might be nice to have, rather than must have in my specific setup. I would love your take if you think I am missing something.
Also, can I ask your opinion on AMD GPUs for this kind of workload? The 7900 XTX is a really attractive price with 24 GB of VRAM, but it seems like ROCm still needs more time and maturity. I will be doing a lot in ComfyUI and LM Studio. Because of that, I am thinking an NVIDIA card with 16 GB of VRAM or more might be the safer bet even if I am planning to do a dual boot. Maybe 24 GB if I get lucky with a used card. I am curious what you have heard has worked for other Framework users doing dual boot working with AI models?
Indeed, Framework 16 OCuLink is PCI 4.0 x 4 on either model, so what you would lose out on with the DEG1 is mostly the extra storage capability. Given the lower price and the urgency, I think if you are set on OCuLink for some time in the future then the DEG1 is a solid choice.
Regarding AMD GPUs and AI, I cannot really provide any feedback as I do not have much experience. My general take would be to get more than 16gb of VRAM if possibe for futureproofing regarding gaming.
But I used the ADT ones. seems pretty nice. Each data pair is individually shielded, for minimum signal loss.
However they are extremely stiff, because they have what seems like 3 layer of plastic. I used a absurd amount of force, and temporarily deformed all of it (the m.2 expansion bay, and the chassis) trying to cram it inside. It worked, but intermittently, and after taking it out I can’t get the oculink adapter to work reliably again (rip).
The laptop and the m.2 carrier is undamaged, dont worry.
The NFHK’s “bracket” version seems like a good compromise. Individually shielded, but with internal type cable, so should be decently flexible consider my SAS connector experience. It’s also loosely bundled, so rotating and making bends should be pretty easy.
