That is correct. It will be available at no charge by request once they have them in stock in quantity. nrp has said he will let us know once they are available.
Rework Instructions for 11th Gen Mainboards to enable powering the RTC circuit from the main battery
I wasn’t worried about paying, I just don’t want to open a ticket and have to do the reset run around/guide ping pong with tech just to prove I can get one.
I would hope it’s as easy as providing the original order number to confirm the purchase of an 11 gen board. That’d be great.
1 Like
Completely agree. I think we’ve endured enough with this problem. Making us jump through extra hoops just to get a fix that everyone with a 11th gen board needs eventually is a bit of a stretch…
Please reconsider your workflow here. Request through support yes, but troubleshooting steps back and forth no…
3 Likes
Have they said they will require troubleshooting steps back and forth in order to receive this module? I know at other times they were suggesting troubleshooting steps while they worked on a solution, but hopefully they won’t require a lot of messing around for those who want this module in order to perform this modification. It didn’t sound to me like they will, but we’ll see I suppose.
1 Like
FWIW, I submitted a ticket and got boilerplate answer to ask for a new coin battery to be sent out. So, the short answer as far as I know, is Support has not yet set up a system for the fake battery solution for I5 users.
Re-read what Nrp last said.
He did not say it’s available right now, and he did not direct anyone to contact support to try to get one. Support is handling very high loads right now. Status of Framework Support (July 31st, 2023)
Framework will let us know when the fulfillment warehouses are stocked, and how to request one when it’s time to.
3 Likes
Folks, please read Nirav’s message. This new single-solder point alternative is NOT ready yet and our Support team is unable to provide either the alternative, or timing, as there’s still work to be done to make it available. Our team will continue to offer a new RTC after troubleshooting determines that the original has been deep-cycled too many times.
@MJ1 is 100% correct. We’ll let the Community know when it’s ready and the part is available in our Service centers. Thank you for your continued patience.
8 Likes
Yes, they have. NRP said (emphasis mine):
This means you need to meet an even higher requirement to get the board. There are two separate issues that manifest differently:
- Your button battery could fail and then your laptop won’t boot if its been off a charger for 10 minutes. This doesn’t require a mainboard reset to fix, all you need is a replacement button battery.
- You could hit the small percent chance that the low voltage on the RTC line causes the machine to become unbootable until you reset the mainboard. This state is different from #1 because plugging in a charger won’t make your laptop boot if you hit this state.
NRP’s post says you have to be in camp #2. Perhaps he misspoke, idk, but I doubt they’re going to be more loose with handing out custom small-volume circuit boards than they are mass-produced standardized dirt cheap batteries, so at a minimum you can expect the same hurdles those of us in camp #1 have had to jump through, which include:
- Tell them when the issue started
- Estimate how long your laptop was left unplugged before the issue started
- Tell them which charger(s) you are using including make, model, and power output
- Check that you are on the latest firmware and take a photo to prove that you are
- Perform the full mainboard reset anyway (even though you don’t need it if you’re in camp #1)
- While your button battery is removed, take a clear photo of the button battery holder
- While your main battery is disconnected, take a clear photo of the allegedly super fragile main battery connector to see if you damaged it.
- Take a photo of your mainboard with “the sticker/shroud removed”
- Put everything back together
- Charge for 24 hours
That is unless Framework finally realizes that every interaction we have with their customer support is rapidly draining the enthusiasm we had for this once-loved product.
(PS, the whole process took 12 days, 3.93 of which was time waiting for framework to respond on email and 4.68 of which was shipping time. The rest of the time was time waiting on me.)
4 Likes
At this point, you may just want to download the files from GitHub and go to PCBWay or something and get it made yourself. Will probably be faster than waiting for and going through support to obtain one.
You guys sure encourage Framework to be public about developing and testing things like this in the future.
And I’m sure if they had rushed it out and there were problems that they didn’t get to work out, you’d give them hell for rushing.
These things take time. I suspect everyone will live.
11 Likes
Is there a possibility to have this workaround and a coin cell? I am afraid if the battery is empty, the BIOS settings will reset.
No not possible – the workaround takes the place of the coin cell.
But don’t worry, the battery is just for the real time clock, not bios – and the workaround provides power from the main battery instead of the coin cell.
The worst case is that you’ll lose the time if your main battery completely depletes – but the machine will restart when you plug-in / recharge the main battery and your OS will reset the time once you’re online.
I’m just going to buy another board later this year. Will be quicker and easier most likely.
I’ll sell the 11th gen on somewhere.
MJ1,
I was replying generally to the other posters who wondered when Support was going to be up and running on this. So I checked. Not yet was the response and that is what I posted, nothing more.
Jason,
I thought about that, but am unwilling to foist this unreliable laptop on an unsuspecting buyer.
Jason, is this the board you are looking at?
Intel® Core™ i7-1165G7
Selling for 400 bucks and I would assume it is a drop in replacement, not sure of course.
Yeah I have the 1165G7 currently. Would get a 12th or 13th gen equivalent later this year.
Someone will be more than happy to buy the old board for a project I’m sure.
If you have an 11th Gen system or Mainboard, you can now reach out to support to request a free RTC Battery Substitute module. To make the request process go smoothly, enter the email address that you ordered the 11th Gen product on and/or include photos of the system and Mainboard serial numbers.
Note that there are no constraints making this request other than being an 11th Gen system or Mainboard owner (whether or not you are in warranty). We ask that you really make sure you are comfortable with performing soldering on expensive electronics items before performing the installation, as we won’t be able to provide advice or support around soldering or provide fixes for failed soldering attempts. We also ask that you only make the request if you’ve faced needing to perform a Mainboard reset, as we want to avoid waste.
14 Likes
Thank you @nrp - I really appreciate that a solution has been found - I look forward to a bit of soldering. For those of us who have a station what temp do you advise for the soldering - I did not see that in the rework instructions.
1 Like
Great news! Thanks for considering the worries that people had about jumping thru hoops – it feels like your asks are totally fair.
1 Like