[RESPONDED] Will the FW13 Haptic trackpad fix Accidental Trackpad Clicks Issue?

I’m wondering, if getting the Framework 13 Pro Haptic input cover might address my trackpad clicking issue.

I basically have this problem (but with an older framework 13 using a mechanical input cover):

In my case, the trackpad will click-in and hold when I grip the laptop around the left-side of the palm rest. This happens even when I’m not touching the trackpad. Basically, The mechanical touchpad will click-in, if I hold the laptop like this:

These accidental clicks happen when I’m gripping the laptop with my thumb on the left-side of the palm rest and the rest of my hand clamping the laptop directly underneath my thumb. I think the bottom cover is flexing and pressing the trackpad button from below.

There are other scenarios where the trackpad will click from below too. I usually run into this issue when I’m trying to use the laptop laying down or on the sofa.

Would replacing my input cover with the haptic input one help?

I’m looking at this one:

I got this Framework 13 a long time ago. It originally had an 11th gen intel mainboard. I’ve been upgrading it and using it as my daily driver. I’m still using the original input cover. I’m not sure when I first noticed this clicking issue… It’s probably been there from the start. But I’ve had this machine for years.

Edit: I re-worked this post to make it easier to read / understand. My original post might have given the impression that I already have a haptic touch pad. I reworked it so that my actual situation is more clear.

Check your system settings. If the trackpad clicks when you aren’t touching it, the computer shouldn’t recognize the click. You can check by clicking the touchpad using your nail or a pencil.

Some says the haptic trackpad is more sensitive but there’s little quantitative measurement.

You can use a Pro bottom chassis to improve the rigidity regardless of what trackpad you are using.

Thanks! I think your reply might have answered my question indirectly:

If the trackpad clicks when you aren’t touching it, the computer shouldn’t recognize the click. You can check by clicking the touchpad using your nail or a pencil.

I think that means that the haptic touchpad must sense someone’s digits or skin in order for the click to actually register. So if someone is not touching the trackpad then it normally won’t activate even if the force sensor detects enough load. I never knew that. That’s very helpful.

I just want to clarify, I don’t have a haptic trackpad. I have an original input cover with a mechanical touchpad. I can see and feel the diving board mechanism “clicking in” when I’m gripping it as shown in the image. I’m not touching the trackpad but my fingers are applying pressure on the button from below.

Sorry I didn’t explain that clearly. For the haptic touchpad, yes, haptic only activates if it senses your finger’s presence and enough force. For the OG non-haptic touchpad, it’ll still mechanically click but your operating system should ignore it and do nothing if you don’t have a finger on it.

1 Like

Thanks. I checked for a setting in Gnome (bluefin / fedora 44). I don’t see a graphical option to disable clicks when not touching the trackpad

For context I also have this set:

❯ gsettings get org.gnome.desktop.peripherals.touchpad click-method 
'fingers'

I’ll check on this again when bluefin 45 / fedora 45 + gnome 51 releases in a few days