Framework supporting far-right racists?

Yeah, semantics. I think people do not really understand anymore where that word came. I guess that’s why it is so easy to casually throw this around, well like this:

But fine. I will leave it there.

2 Likes

I don’t really understand, what you are implying here. Hitler came to power already in the beginning of 1933, in the next month, the Reichstag was on fire. So obviously yes, it was Nazi-Germany in 1934.

I agree that there is a “far-right” administration in the US. Can we call this a Nazi-US, right now ? No. It does not mean that there is dictatorship in the USA in the future, maybe even in the quite near future. It does mean that its ”March, 1933” in the USA, yet.

Same with DHH. After reading his blogpost:

Do I think he has at least some far-right views ? Yes.

Is he a nationalist ? Yes.

Is he against mass-immigration ? Yes! But does he call for mass-deportation of immigrants ? Its debatable, it could be interpreted as being against mass-immigration and then its not the same thing.

Is he a nazi ? I dont think so. And I am not gonna even debate about that. Could he be that in the future ? Who knows, but we cannot imply automatically that he is.

2 Likes

Why is this tagged with expansion-cards and expansion-bay-shell? It’s not related to either of those topics.

If gratifying my own ego implicitly means I won’t be supporting genocide and discrimination against innocent people, then I’ll be the first to say I’ll take it

12 Likes

That’s what effectively many people are calling for in my country in overpopulated cities - those who were not born in $BIGCITY should be moved to their home towns / villages. It’s implied they will not get out.

Obviously it’s not happening (except during Covid). Just deal with it.

The governments actually like to concentrate people in few areas… because it’s cheaper to provide communal services and is good for business. :slight_smile:

You have actually valid points. CECOT is indeed horrible. And we definitely have some common ground.

All I am asking is just to be fair. But other opinions are other opinions and I try to respect these.

But I will stop actually here. I think I cannot continue this personally anymore, maybe because topic is quite sensitive and challenging as well and I wish well for Framework - as this whole thread is too controversial and I am afraid of doing more damage than good by taking part of it.

I will now leave this topic muted…

4 Likes

It takes a long time to shape one’s beliefs. I don’t think these can be changed on a forum thread and I make no attempts to do so with yours or anyone else’s. You have every right to take your custom to or from any business that isn’t aligned to your views. I have no issue with this.

However, I do have an issue with imposing one’s beliefs and politics onto a company and having the expectation that company falls into that mould. Voting with your choice and your wallet according to your moral compass is noble. I respect it. Where the veil of nobility dissolves is when the need to force compliance to your worldview takes over.

It’s not enough to leave silently and take your custom elsewhere. You need to shout about it on every platform, convince others, engage with everyone who beliefs otherwise, establish your righteousness over theirs, demand apologies, demand change. This isn’t noble, neither kind, nor worthy of respect. This is the egocentric characteristic I spoke about. And it is time we stopped entertaining it.

1 Like

This is how those came into effect indeed. But comparing them to the present situation is apples to oranges. What we have here is a very classic case of left vs right ideology. You’re living in a predominanently (and increasingly) conservative world. As recent years have shown, all of the left’s enthusiasm on minority issues has alieanated the masses and pushed more and more people to the right. So with this in mind, keep up the effort. :slight_smile:

I will add that all of the movements behind those issues were largely laser-focused on their specific issue. Today, the left has forgone that and is attempting to force the world to become more inclusive in every conceivable way all at once, which is never how social change has ever worked.

Expecting the world to drastically change immediately and calling everyone who has any level of concerns regarding this a “fascist” or a “Nazi" is causing immense damage to the entire progressive movement. People who have progressive beliefs but a more realistic belief in implementing them (like me) are instead met with accusations of supporting the opposite side merely due to not sharing their extremist beliefs. And it’s left to the right to recruit these disillusioned individuals, which is the mechanism which has led to the resurgence of far-right politics that we’re currently seeing.

2 Likes

A number of folks have reached out to us over the last few days to ask that we share more about which organizations we sponsor. This is certainly something we should have been doing already for transparency, and today we’ve published the list of all of our 2025 sponsorships so far, which total around $215,000. We’ll be keeping this list up to date over time. In addition, we would love nominations of a broader set of mission-aligned organizations we can sponsor, and we’ve created a submission form for this. As you can see from the list for this year, our focus is primarily around funding organizations developing Linux distros and window managers, open source firmware, educational organizations doing open source hardware development, and open source infrastructure that our hardware products and website depend on.

Since this thread started in part around our donation to Hyprland, we wanted to provide additional specific context there. We decided a few months ago to be more deliberate about funding the maturity of the Linux desktop by providing support to both distros and window managers. On the latter, we started sponsorship discussions with the GNOME Foundation ($1,000/month), KDE Foundation ($10,000/year), and Hyprland (600€/month) at the same time, with the plan to announce them together. We sent the funding to Hyprland and GNOME Foundation last week, and have been working with KDE Foundation to finalize our sponsorship. We’ve also been working with GNOME Foundation on announcement timing, as they needed to update the sponsor list on their site. We missed on letting Hyprland know that we wanted to announce these together, and they shared the sponsorship shortly after receiving it last week.

On Hyprland specifically, we were aware that there was past toxicity and controversy in their community, so we did research into it before deciding if we could sponsor the project. What we found was that there were past failures in moderation early in the creation of the project that had resulted in a toxic community, that the project lead vaxry had overhauled moderation years ago as a result, and that the community as it currently stands does not represent the one in which the issues occurred. Over the last few days, we’ve gotten additional outreach from others in the community who were initially concerned about our sponsorship of Hyprland who did their own research and came to a similar conclusion to what we did.

Going forward on this topic:

  1. We are going to continue to update our list of sponsorships as we go to give transparency on what we’re monetarily backing. As noted above, in general we want to coordinate the updates with the organizations we sponsor so that their website updates and announcements happen around the same time as ours.

  2. We’re requesting that you provide additional nominations of mission-aligned organizations that we should sponsor. Note that in the near-to-mid term, we’re still prioritizing organizations focused on open source firmware, software, and hardware that make the ecosystem around our products more mature and accessible. If you have recommendations of other good organizations, please feel free to submit those in the form as well, but they may come into future funding cycles.

  3. Before we sponsor an organization, we will continue to research and confirm that as they currently exist, they uphold appropriate community standards and are structurally set up for that to continue to be the case.

  4. Although this thread has continuously spiraled into unproductive directions that have needed active moderation, we do still plan to keep it open for now and merge additional related new threads into it. Please remember to follow our forum rules though and keep conversation productive and free of personal attacks.

53 Likes

Thank you @nrp. I’m a little confused though. You previously said:

I don’t see Omarchy or any of these other distros listed in the blog post, except for perhaps the hardware donation to NixCon representing a donation to NixOS. Perhaps some of the donations above didn’t happen in 2025, so they wouldn’t be in the blog post. But Omarchy was created in 2025. Could you explain this discrepancy? Maybe I’m missing something.

11 Likes

The list includes monetary sponsorships and unit donations, but not units sent for marketing (e.g. press units) or development purposes, some of which is pre-release hardware we send under NDA. These are marketing/R&D expenses rather than donations, but also, we haven’t been doing good record-keeping in the past on these. The list in my earlier post (“Fedora, Bluefin, Bazzite, NixOS, Arch Linux, Linux Mint, Omarchy, and many other distros”) was a subset of R&D units we sent to open source developers in 2025.

Edit: We’re updating the blog post to clarify this point further.

17 Likes

Corporate lingo aside, this is honestly a really disappointing response. Most of us in this thread have already somewhat established that Hyprland put a lot of effort into making their community more inclusive, but most debates in this entire thread had nothing / very little to do with Hyprland. You haven’t addressed anything regarding Omarchy, which is the main concern here. Why did you [Framework] keep posting about Omarchy on Twitter? As an extension to this, why did you then post about being pro-immigration and pro-LGBTQ+ also on Twitter, especially when DHH has clearly shown to be against both?

I’m willing to put my opportunities of being hired by the Foundation on the line, if it means not listing Framework on the site as it stands, until addressed properly. What y’all did was not okay, to put it bluntly.

33 Likes

I want to update my previous statements to lower my level of outrage. I was under the impression there was a monetary contribution to Omarchy.

8 Likes

How is it disappointing? It simply means Framework didn’t sponsor Omarchy to begin with. Nirav just sent a laptop to the developer, maybe did so out of his pocket for the sole purpose of R&D that at the moment he deemed beneficial. Framework account posted about Omarchy because it’s a popular distro. Framework posts about popular stuff in OSS/OSHW communities every single day. It doesn’t mean Framework sponsors any of those projects.

5 Likes

This was already answered in the same comment:

Sending one or more laptops for free is giving money with extra steps; promoting them on social media is still promoting them.

Well…

12 Likes

While I don’t agree on Vaxry at all, my issue with whats being said now is its in stark contrast with what you said initially - from “Big Tent” to “We don’t think its a problem anymore”.

Then not addressing DHH at all, or the substantially higher marketing/promotion that went to omarchy, or the fact that its extremely obvious how much that situation has not changed.

That is… unfortunate.

I think I’ll have to stick to my previous comment then. I really do hope this changes in the future for the better.

27 Likes

It would be ideal to address Omarchy and DHH specifically. Because he is the main and deepest concern.

You’re still giving them hardware and paying for the cost of those hardware.
Would you please answer the deep concerns and issues with DHH head on?

22 Likes

Because people are (rightfully) angry with DHH, who happens to maintain that distro. Nirav and probably some other people in Framework liked the distro, made posts about it (like, they did with thousand other projects that they share but don’t endorse and who knows if they have awful maintainers) and eventually decided to send a laptop so its further developed. Its obviously not an official sponsorship and Nirav/other people in Framework didn’t re-iterated their support of Omarchy in any shape of form (like, they did with Hyprland which got rid of toxicity) which should be telling what they think of DHH.

Framework making posts about them != sponsorship. As I said, Framework shares every OSS/OSHW stuff that they like on their Twitter account. Maybe some of them have authors even worse than DHH, who knows? Its actually why Framework needs and constantly searches for a social media manager and content creator as you may have noticed. Nirav, after all, is a human being and has toooo much on his plate. He is also an engineer, not a communications/PR specialist. Nirav himself made a short saying he needs help, and they are still looking for a social media manager everywhere, to avoid miscommunication as it happens now.

For the laptop given to DHH, just have some emphaty for a microsecond and put yourself in Nirav’s position. In Turkish we have a saying “verilen mal geri alınmaz“, which means you can’t get back what you gave. Nirav just gave it to DHH, how do you expect him to get it back without further damaging, like, everything? What would you do in such situation? What he can do at max is to not share anything about this distro anymore + not sponsoring it which is literally the current situation. He can’t get it back, he can’t do anything else other than not further collaborating with Omarchy. While you write, have you thought about Nirav’s mental health as much as you have thought about DHH’s racism and transphobia? This amount of heavy pressure on a single human what drives some people to self-h*rm and even s*icide.

7 Likes