basic recommendation to use those spring loaded microsd slot things for the expansion card so it can seat flush, and be easily removed by pressing it. sorry this is short, just something I really hope is implemented in the near future.
9 Likes
AFAIK the sd card expansion slot is not spring loaded, because it gives it higher durability. I dont have a source for it, though. Just something I read.
1 Like
I have an idea for an expansion card: SD card launcher⊠
2 Likes
Idk where to put this, but the sd card module could use that action where you can push on the sd card and it would pop out, making easier removal. If itâs not possible than itâs fine.
1 Like
This really needed to be spring loaded (actually, I think the cards themselves needed to be but I bet the Framework 13 style case is locked in for a decade now)
I have a lot of difficulty taking the MicroSD cards out and it is never clear when they are inserted correctly.
I would say a full size SDXC reader with a good quality UHS-II adapter card would work better.
1 Like
They are working on one. But it requires them having a custom SD slot made.
Interestingly, the slots were originally going to have springs, but this was determined to not be the best option for the user experience. See more here
1 Like
That is interesting. Especially considering every other microUSB drive Iâve ever used was spring loaded. It never occured to me that Frameworks wouldnât be
2 Likes
The expansion cards themselves were originally spring-loaded, which had the unintended effect of launching them out of the laptop.
Some may see that as a feature though.
2 Likes
Correct, I should note that I was talking about the expansion cards themselves originally being spring loaded. We donât know about the pre-production of the MicroSD expansion card, but non spring loaded slots do exist on many computers other than the Framework Laptop.
While there could always be a MicroSD expansion v2 that adds a spring loaded mechanism, it does not seem to be a priority for the team right now, as they are currently working on a full-size SD expansion card.
1 Like
I love my Framework 13 but have a MicroSD card plugged in all the time and it sticking out drives me a bit insane. Not sure if it is in the cards or not but would love a V2 of the reader expansion card that is spring-loaded so that it is flush with the case.
1 Like
Welcome to the forum.
There is the new full size SD expansion card. You could try that plus a short microSD to SD adapter. Example: ebay.com/itm/175975158720
Does the full size SD card not stick out of the adapter? I assumed it was the same.
It does. Thatâs the reason youâd buy a short microSD to SD adapter.
Welcome to the forum.
Yes itâs one of my âhatesâ
I previously used one as an encrypted volume for personal and email etc. having it poking out means it is not physically secure. I have travelled with the ”SD in but itâs a bit unnerving.
Apparently the spring version was tried and the developers decided against it as it could pop out. However on my 2 in 1 and tablet it never happened.
Another alternative it have like a phone > a fully inserted that requires a paper clip type pin to eject it.
And although Framework does read the forum I doubt this will get any traction. It may be âtimeâ to email them directly.
Still after nearly 2.5 years Iâm resigned to what I have and will not be replacing it.
Waiting for a new model with touchscreen and this sorted . . . . . . .
Not sure what @MJ1 is getting at ?? I thought the idea is not to have anything sticking out ???
Unless the idea is that a half size SD adapter will enclose it Hmm!
Yes, thatâs the idea. I believe those half size SD adapters were originally made for macbooks, which also stupidly had the cards stick out. The half size SD adapters work nicely for Raspberry Pis as well. Green Shortening microSD adapter for Raspberry Pi & Macbooks : ID 1693 : Adafruit Industries, Unique & fun DIY electronics and kits
But Storage Expansion Card looks better in your use case: Framework | Storage Expansion Card (2nd Gen) ?
Outside FwkLaptop it will be just odd usb pendrive.
Yes tried that too but doesnât work. Pet hate #2
The âcardâ disconnects and reconnects with increasing frequency. I had an open encrypted volume on it and lost data etc. Without the encrypted volume, which brings up a warning itâs not so noticeable, but thatâs why I wanted it.
I tried different slots, added internal heat pad to aluminium case, everything I tried made temp fixes. This happened under the watchful eye of Framework until just as my two years was up it failed altogether. I was send a replacement under warranty but itâs the same ~ unreliable dismounts | ejects
The two expansion cards that I thought would make my day are a bit of a nightmare.
Am hesitant to make another issue of this with Framework as itâs depressing.
UPDATE: Notified moderator to merge here and now have found
The one thing that I find disappointing with my new Framework 13 is the microSD expansion card. I have an extremely difficult time getting the card out of the slot because itâs the type of slot where there is no spring to eject the card. This is literally the one thing that I miss from my old XPS 13. Iâve got a soldering station and probably more confidence than I should. Would it be possible to swap the slot types? I have googled around and I have found nothing. But I also have no idea what the technical terms are for the parts Iâm looking for.
I guess maybe another option is to find a usb-c type external port and try to mod that into a card?
Welcome to the forum.
Those push-to-eject slots are commonly known as âpush pushâ. microSD Memory Card Connectors â Mouser Youâll see in the item description âpush pushâ or âP-P typeâ, one company using âAuto Eject Outâ. You can also find them on aliexpress by searching âpush push micro SDâ aliexpress.com/w/wholesale-push-push-micro-sd.html or ebay.
Youâll have to find one with a similar enough pin pad layout to at least fit the communication pads on the circuit board. Mounting pads would be less important, since if they donât line up, you could instead use glue.
1 Like