But that situation cannot really develop when the laptops are locked down in the first place.
Framework has built much of its identity around openness, yet this decision actively undermines that principle. And my question is: why?
The cost of allowing an unlocked platform should be minimal. From a manufacturing perspective, it essentially comes down to offering an alternative factory firmware and Boot Guard provisioning configuration, rather than permanently locking the platform through irreversible fuses.
Nobody is asking Framework to develop or maintain Coreboot themselves. The community can do that. Quite possibly including me - I’m currently porting Coreboot to my own hardware and already have a corporate NDA with Intel.
Maybe it wouldn’t happen immediately. Maybe it wouldn’t be suitable for everyone. But Framework would eventually benefit from a community-supported firmware alternative, attracting more technically minded customers and gaining an excellent marketing opportunity. At very little cost to the company.
And Intel is actually far more Coreboot-friendly than AMD. Intel provides FSP, contributes its own reference platforms and development board ports to upstream Coreboot, and generally offers a much more accessible environment for independent firmware development. AMD, by comparison, is practically a desert in this regard. The difference is striking once you start working with these platforms yourself.
What I would genuinely like to understand is why Framework insists on enforcing Intel Boot Guard in the first place.
Intel doesn’t require it. They provide the mechanism, but the decision to enforce it rests with the manufacturer.
Is it about maintaining control over the platform? If so, why? Especially for a company that makes openness such a central part of its identity?
At this rate, Framework might actually convince me to build an open motherboard for their chassis instead of buying one of their laptops. Not exactly the outcome they were aiming for, I imagine.
I’m already working on my own hardware design, although currently only around the Intel N300. The problem is that I genuinely can’t find a laptop worth buying: the manufacturers offering more open platforms tend to have mechanical designs that really don’t meet my expectations.
And I suspect I could find at least a few other people interested in a genuinely open motherboard that fits a well-designed Framework chassis.
It would be rather ironic if Framework’s biggest contribution to open laptops ended up being the chassis, while the community had to replace the motherboard to get the openness.